Extending deadline on Save Our Homes portability makes sense | Editorial

1/31/2020

Tampa Bay Times

Click Here To Read Online

People who sell their houses covered by a homestead exemption have two years to move into a new house and carry that tax break along with them. Except they really don’t. Pinellas County Property Appraiser Mike Twitty proposes extending the Florida deadline to three years, a commonsense fix that state lawmakers should ask voters to approve.

To transfer the Save Our Homes exemption, Florida law says a homeowner must have “received a homestead exemption as of Jan. 1 of either of the two immediately preceding years.” So someone could easily miss out by selling a home late in the year and then building a new home that isn’t finished by New Year’s of the year after next — in other words, after only a year and a few days had passed.

Twitty’s idea has now taken the form of legislation. SB 148 and HB 369, sponsored respectively by Sen. Jeff Brandes, R-St. Petersburg, and Rep. Rick Roth, R-West Palm Beach, would place a constitutional amendment on the November ballot that would add a year to the period when homeowners can transfer their accumulated benefits. If the amendment goes on the ballot, 60 percent of the voters would have to approve it for the change to be added to the Constitution. If the amendment passed, Save Our Homes would still allow homeowners to carry up to $500,000 in accumulated reduction in their assessment from one home to another. All the amendment would do is extend this portability to three years.

This simple change means that the Constitution would reflect what voters intended, that homeowners could take their exemption with them for two full years or more — and not lose it in the space of a year and a few days. Lawmakers should put this sensible change on the ballot, and voters should approve the amendment in November.

Posted by user in News, 0 comments

Bills would give Florida home buyers more time to safeguard valuable tax break

1/24/2020

Tampa Bay Times

Click Here To Read Online

CLEARWATER — It wouldn’t help the Tampa family who camped in a tent outside their unfinished house, and it would require amending Florida’s constitution.

But Pinellas County Property Appraiser Mike Twitty believes legislation before the House and Senate could help homeowners carry a potent property tax break from one home to another.

Two bills, House bill 369 and Senate bill 148, would schedule a constitutional referendum for this November on whether to add a year to the period when homeowners can transfer their accumulated benefits under the Save Our Homes property tax assessment cap to a new house.

It’s an issue worth thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars a year in property taxes for some Florida homeowners.

Save Our Homes limits the growth of tax assessments on homes with homestead property tax exemptions to 3 percent a year. In the kind of booming real estate and construction market Florida has now, the difference between the Save Our Homes capped assessment and what it would be without the cap can grow quickly from year to year and build up.

Save Our Homes also allows homeowners to carry the accumulated reduction in their assessment, up to $500,000, from one home to another. This is called portability, but it comes with a deadline.

Florida law currently says a homeowner must have “received a homestead exemption as of Jan. 1 of either of the two immediately preceding years” in order to transfer Save Our Homes benefits from one home to the next.

“Problem is, it’s not really two years,” Twitty says, especially if a home is sold later in the year. In the case of a home sold in late December of 2019, for example, the homestead exemption would no longer be there on Jan. 1, 2020. If the owner doesn’t buy and move into a new home by Jan. 1, 2021, a homestead wouldn’t be established at the new residence within the current portability timeframe. So in the space of a year and a few days, not two full years, the portability period would have expired.

The poster couple for what happens when the deadline is missed is L. Lowry and Jennifer Baldwin of Tampa.

When the Baldwins sold their old home in 2013 and the builder of their new home took longer than expected, they pitched a tent in the yard of the house under construction in an effort to show that it was their permanent residence and thus should be eligible for a homestead exemption before the portability period expired after Jan. 1, 2015.

The Hillsborough County Property Appraiser’s Office said camping out didn’t qualify, and so far Florida courts have agreed. The Baldwins are trying to take the case to the Florida Supreme Court. Because they lost their portability, the taxes on their new $2.15 million home are about $5,200 a year more than they would be with portability.

“Adding another year certainly would have alleviated some of the problems confronting the Baldwins, particularly in a situation where you have a contractor who’s not finishing on time,” said Tampa attorney Rob Kelley, who represents the couple.

It also would make the application of the law more uniform across the state, he said, adding that he knows of a similar case in Miami-Dade County where the property appraiser allowed the homeowner to transfer the benefit.

“There are many counties in Florida that would have allowed them to port their value under their circumstances,” Kelley said. “You shouldn’t be penalized or rewarded based just on the county you reside in.”

Extending the period to three years would create more of a certain two-year window that’s consistent with the common understanding of the intent of the law, Twitty says. If passed, the change wouldn’t affect the Baldwins, but because it would go into effect on Jan. 1, 2021, Twitty says it could help people who sold homes in 2018.

It also would reduce the possibility of a delay in construction keeping someone out of their new home or condominium in time to establish their homestead exemption.

When “I came into office in early ’17, I knew it was going to be an issue with all the construction we’re having and everybody moving around,” Twitty says.

So he pitched the idea to legislators and watched bills die before the end of the last two legislative sessions. This year, the bills are sponsored by state Sen. Jeff Brandes, R-St. Petersburg, and Rep. Rick Roth, R-West Palm Beach. But even if they win the approval of the full Legislature, the change still requires passage of a constitutional amendment, so 60 percent of Florida voters would have to approve it at a statewide referendum on Nov. 3.

For the handful of hard cases his office sees every month, Twitty thinks it would be worth the effort.

“I think a lot of the ones that miss the window we don’t hear from,” he says, but “typically several times a month we end up with people that just miss” the deadline.

“We’ve had some odd situations where people … might have put sleeping bags in the floor of an unfinished house to try to sleep in there before Jan. 1,” he says. “Some of them understand. They say, ‘Well, we had to try.’ Others can be quite upset. Some say, ‘I’m building this house now, and as soon as it’s finished, I’m going to have to sell it because I can’t afford the taxes.’ ”

The fiscal impact of the change is estimated to be minuscule.

Extending the deadline by another year would reduce local government property tax revenues by a total of $2.1 million at first, according to a legislative staff analysis. Later it would ramp up to a statewide loss of $6.5 million in property tax revenues. That would be a revenue loss of .00018 percent out of the $35.7 billion in property taxes that local governments levied statewide last year.

“This would eliminate a bunch of heartache and some of the gamesmanship that ends up occurring with people trying to figure out how to get under the wire when they’ve legitimately missed it,” Twitty says. “Most of the time when they do miss it, it’s not by more than six months or so.”

Posted by user in News, 0 comments

How much could Amendment 1 save you in property taxes? Pinellas Appraiser Mike Twitty created a statewide tool to estimate potential savings.

3/16/2020

Tampa Bay Times

Click To Read Online

With a controversial amendment on November’s ballot that could expand Florida’s homestead exemption, Pinellas County Property Appraiser Mike Twitty wants homeowners to know how much they could save.

Twitty, working with data from 59 other property appraisers, created a tool that lets homeowners estimate how much money they could save in property taxes if Amendment 1 passes.

Twitty created the tool because Florida voters often head into a “general election without a true understanding of how a property tax law change to our state constitution directly impacts them,” he said.

“This tool allows property owners to see the facts relating to their own real estate,” Twitty said in a statement.

“The property appraisers are the keepers of this data and are best suited to provide information and transparency to our citizens so they are better informed before heading to the polls on Nov. 6th.”

The measure would increase the homestead exemption from $50,000 to $75,000, but the additional $25,000 exemption would apply only to homes with an assessed value of $100,000 or more.

Assessed values between $100,000 and $125,000 would be exempt from taxation. Amendment 1 will not apply to school taxes.

The tool allows homeowners to enter their address to see how much they could potentially save: http://www.3hxestimator.org

As a result, property appraisers have created links to the tool on their websites. These seven counties did not participate: Baker, Clay, Collier, Dixie, Highlands, Leon and Orange.

The Legislature passed the measure in 2017 and it will require 60 percent of the vote to pass. It has already raised concerns among county and municipal leaders across the Sunshine State.

In Pinellas, only 56 percent of those homesteaded would receive either a partial or full benefit from the additional exemption, Twitty added. Statewide, it’s 61 percent, he added.

In 2017, Pinellas County predicted it could lose $17 million in property taxes in unincorporated areas in 2020. That figure  has now climbed to $21.7 million, Twitty said. Hillsborough froze hiring in 2017 because of the amendment.

The statewide impact is expected to cost $644 million per year—resulting in either service reductions or tax hikes. Most benefits will only go to a handful of homeowners, according to the Florida City and County Management Association.

In calculating the potential savings, Twitty listed these disclaimers on the website:

  • All calculations are based on 2017 assessment roll data and 2017 final tax rates.
  • Recent purchases in 2017 and 2018 may show $0 benefit as a new homestead application may not yet be reflected at this address.
  • Assessed value must exceed $100,000 to receive any benefit from the 3rd Homestead Exemption.
  • Full (100%) benefit from the 3rd Homestead Exemption is not received unless your property’s Assessed Value is greater than or equal to $125,000.
  • Estimates assume no partial homesteads. Homestead percentages less than 100% would result in a lower estimate.
  • If passed, this exemption would take effect January 1, 2019 for the 2019 tax year.
Posted by user in News, 0 comments
Load more
Close Bitnami banner
Bitnami